The testing of what appears to have been a miniaturised hydrogen bomb by the North Korean regime has further heightened tensions between Pyongyang and the international community. The US, Russian and Chinese governments all released statements condemning the development, with President Trump tweeting that “talk of appeasement” was not working.
Fundamentally, North Korea poses an almost insoluble problem to the rest of the world. Negotiating with a dictator who has access to nuclear weapons and boasts of plans to attack the West is nigh on impossible; yet equally no military initiative could realistically bring peace without a great deal of destruction first. This has been the dilemma for more than a decade, since the Agreed Framework between North Korea and the US – under which the former’s nuclear programme was to be radically downsized in return for a slow normalisation of relations – broke down finally in 2003.
Since that time, the strategic objectives of the North Koreans have been broadly consistent: first, to build up a sufficiently sophisticated arsenal of weapons that the international community cannot take military action without risking almost certain catastrophe in the region; second, to convince the West (but ultimately the US) that Pyongyang has the capacity to strike first.
Trump, May and other world leaders condemn North Korea’s nuclear test
Most observers argue that these policies are driven by a belief that only such strongman tactics will ultimately create an atmosphere in which the international community accepts that it must negotiate with North Korea over the question of sanctions, which – in part because of Pyongyang’s spending of resources on its military – continue to make economic growth in the country impossible.
What has changed in the past year is that the rapid refinement of North Korea’s missile and nuclear programmes has coincided with the election to the American presidency of the most unpredictable character to ever hold the office. With each passing week his attitude towards Pyongyang appears to shift. We have had the threat to bring “fire and fury” to Kim Jong-un’s pariah state; then 10 days ago, Mr Trump suggested that the North Koreans were beginning to respect America; now he says that appeasement is ineffective.
Such unpredictability is dangerous for all sorts of reasons, especially when nuclear warheads are involved. Yet it is particularly problematic when it comes to…